History
Making private property affordable
by Shirley Tan-Oehler and Yip Soo Hui

While private property developers build projects for the sole purpose of making profits, NTUC Choice Homes Co-operative Limited does it to help families to improve their lifestyles.

The idea of the National Trades Union Congress establishing a housing cooperative arose in 1995. The aim was to help more Singaporeans meet their aspirations to own private property by delivering quality housing at fair and affordable prices. Beyond this responsibility, NTUC Choice Homes has now also made it its business to achieve two self-set social performance indicators - to sell properties at prices generally below the average price for comparable properties and passing savings from projects back to purchasers.

Property prices had shot up by 36% in 1993 and 42% in 1994. With rising affluence, a growing number of Singaporeans aspired to live in private housing but they could not afford to do so.

Mr Lim Boon Heng, Secretary-General of NTUC, told NTUC News (6 January 1995) that land cost, construction cost and profit margin of the developer were three factors that largely contributed to the prices of private property. As land and construction costs were fixed by the market, how much the developer could make at the end of the project would depend on whether or not there would be high demand for it.

Mr Lim felt that by becoming a developer, NTUC's housing cooperative could curb upward swings in prices by selling properties at lower profit margins. It would build condominiums to meet the needs of middle-income earners who had difficulty upgrading from Housing Board flats because of spiralling property prices.

In August 1995, Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong, in his National Day Rally speech, announced that HDB would stop building executive flats and those in the queue for such flats would be diverted to the soon-to-be formed Executive Condominium (EC) line to meet the needs of graduate couples and HDB upgraders for private housing. Initially, Pidemco, a Government-Linked Company, would build these ECs in Jurong East and Pasir Ris. If demand for such housing was good, the government would invite other non-profit organisations, such as housing cooperatives, to participate in the new scheme.

NTUC Choice Homes was registered in November 1995 with more than $63 million of contributions coming from NTUC, the Singapore Labour Foundation (SLF), 43 affiliated unions, NTUC Income Co-operative Limited and NTUC Fairprice Co-operative Limited.

In launching NTUC Choice Homes in July 1996, Mr Lim said: "Choice Homes can help set benchmarks for the price and quality of mid-range condominiums and apartments. Not only will this provide buyers with more choices, it will also give them a better idea of pricing and quality, for them to make more informed comparisons and decisions. By providing the alternative, we hope it will have some effect on moderating prices in the market."

It certainly did. By launching Simei Green at $410 psf and Yew Mei Green at $430 psf, developers of properties within the two vicinities were forced to review and bring down their prices to attract buyers.

From its first project, Simei Green Executive Condominium, to its fifth, Bishan Loft, an Executive Condominium which is expected to be granted Temporary Occupation Permit (TOP) at end-2003 -NTUC Choice Homes has returned some $4 million in savings to more than 2,000 homeowners. The developer did this in various ways, by absorbing stamp fees, between three and 12 months of maintenance fees, contributing to the sinking funds and purchasing shopping vouchers and NTUC LinkPoints for eligible buyers.

In September 2002, NTUC Choice Homes launched a 391-unit Park Green Executive Condominium in Sengkang at an average price of $368 psf, setting new benchmarks for the pricing and quality of executive condominiums yet again. In support of the labour movement, 10% of the units were set aside for union leaders and members in an exclusive preview. As was the case in its other EC project, NTUC Choice Homes also set aside 5% of the units for grassroots leaders. To-date, 70% of the units have been sold.

Besides residential projects, NTUC Choice Homes has also built Rivervale Mall. Operational since the fourth quarter of 2000, it has maintained 100% tenancy rate at satisfactory rental. The Mall was sold to NTUC Fairprice Co-operative Limited in December 2002.

In its last annual report released in September 2002, Board Chairman, Mr Ng Ser Miang, said NTUC Choice Homes will continue to source for new development sites to keep alive its mission of providing more Singaporeans with quality living that is within their reach. He also gave the assurance that NTUC Choice Homes directors will continue to take a prudent approach to the development of any project.

Newly-appointed Chief Executive Officer, Miss Adeline Sum, echoed his sentiments. She feels the property market will remain weak in the next six to 12 months. "But, NTUC Choice Homes will continue to launch projects at affordable prices to meet real needs, instead of trying to hold out for the market to turn," she said.

As NTUC Choice Homes offers preferential treatment to union leaders and union members in the allocation of every property it launches, with grassroots leaders next in line ahead of other members of the public, it pays to belong to the NTUC family.

Simei Green Executive Condominium in Simei. Average $410 psf. 602 homeowners. $500,000 in savings passed back to purchasers through absorption of 3 months' maintenance fees and a $100,000 contribution to sinking fund. Project completed.
Yew Mei Green Executive Condominium in Yew Tee. Average $430 psf. 712 homeowners. 3 per cent stamp fees absorbed. $600,000 in savings passed back to purchasers through absorption of 3 months' maintenance fees and a $164,000 contribution to sinking fund. As a gesture of goodwill, those who bought their units at higher prices before the property market plunge were offered $1,000 gift vouchers from selected retail outlets when TOP was granted. Project completed.
Rivervale Crest Private property in Sengkang, a Mediterranean-style project. Average $458 psf. 490 homeowners. 3 per cent stamp fees absorbed for all new purchasers from April 2002. 12 months' maintenance fees of $1.56 million absorbed plus $341,000 worth of NTUC LinkPoints given to 107 homeowners who purchased their units during the soft launch. Project completed.
Bishan Loft Executive Condominium in Bishan. Average $418 psf. 384 homeowners. $100,000 worth of NTUC LinkPoints will be purchased for the 38 union members who bought units in the development. About 70 per cent of the project was sold within a day, 100 per cent sold out within one weekend. Construction is progressing on schedule and TOP is expected at end-2003.
Park Green Executive Condominium in Sengkang, a modern and hi-tech looking development. 391 units. Launched in September 2002 at an average price of $368 psf. TOP is expected in end-2004.
Ang Mo Kio s2a Private 99-year at Ang Mo Kio Avenue 8. A modern-themed development with multi-tiered landscape. Joint-venture with Chip Eng Leong Enterprise. To be launched in second half of 2003.
Ang Mo Kio Town Centre Development Private 99-year, 135-unit apartment block at Ang Mo Kio Avenue 8/Avenue 3, part of a mixed development comprising residential, office and retail components. To be launched in 2004.
Riviera Drive Exclusive freehold condominium in Riveria Drive, off Upper East Coast Road. 135 units. Yet to be launched.